Small Group Study: Judging
One of the most serious critiques Christians get from non-Christians is we are judgmental. People say all the time, “Christians aren’t supposed to judge other people” and yet most only see Christians as that. For instance, watch this short video clip of basketball legend Charles Barkley:
Of course you probably don’t agree with everything he just said, but it’s easy to focus on our areas of disagreement and not seek to understand where he’s coming from. His perspective, I mean.
Right or wrong, his perspective is that Christians are unauthentic, hypocritical – and particularly when it comes to judging others. But the real question for us is: Is he right? Are we not supposed to judge people? As a small group, watch the video and discuss this topic. Here are some possible questions you can talk about:
- Does the bible say we can’t judge others? If so, where?
- In Matthew 7:1-5, what is the principle Jesus is trying to get across? Is it a blanket statement to not judge anyone, for any reason?
- Read Matthew 18:15-20 and discuss how to reconcile this with Matthew 7:1-5.
- Does the bible distinguish between judging believers and judging those who don’t believe? After some discussion, Read 1 Corinthians 5:1-8 and talk about this question based on Paul’s statement. Is this acceptable only because this person is a part of the church, or is this universally applicable? (Also talk about the end goal of his statement, this is important.) Read 1 Corinthians 5:12-13 and talk about it’s implications.
- Is there a balance between judging others and confronting sin? If so, what is it and how do we keep that balance? (see Titus 3:3-5 for thoughts)
Ok, I know this study has some holes in it. That’s where you come in and hopefully the discussion fills in. Part of the fun…

Well, I wasn’t able to attend because I was speaking somewhere else, but this past weekend was Passion2010. Approximately 20,000 college age people from all over the country (and even beyond) packed an arena for one weekend. They heard some of the top communicators in the church today – Francis Chan, Louie Giglio, Beth Moore, Andy Stanley…on and on and sang along with some of the best worship leaders in the church today – David Crowder, Chris Tomlin, Charlie Hall, Kristian Stanfill, Steve Fee…on and on.